The Standing Rock Resistance

Describe the specific global ethical issue you will address for this topic.

Standing Rock Resistance was a movement led mainly by the indigenous Sioux Tribe. It strived to gain global recognition as a struggle for environmental justice, indigenous rights, and corporate entity legal victory. This paper examines the clash between a general impulse for development and indigenous peoples’ rights as a particular global ethical problem. The subject of this paper will be environmental ethics, with an emphasis on the demonstration of how Standing Rock epitomizes the battle between economic and environmental preservation.

Name the focus.

The focus of standing rock resistance is environmental ethics, which encompasses an analysis of the ethical approach through which human beings relate or deal with the environment. Within this focus, the specified topic is The Standing Rock Resistance, the movement that emerged in response to the intended construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL). This theme involves the question of what indigenous people’s rights to land and resources combine with the environmentalist desire to preserve indigenous territories from external exploitation.

Name the theme you will address within that focus.

The most crucial ethical concern that can be associated with the Standing Rock Resistance is one that embodies economic development versus environmental protection and concern for the rights of indigenous people. Policy-making for the DAPL was built upon the promise of employment opportunities and boosting domestic energy security. The pipeline came with high risks in as much as it would potentially cover sacred grounds of the Standing Rock Sioux tribe and also pose a threat to the Missouri River, which is a vital source of water for the tribe. This ethical dilemma resulted in taking into consideration the potential short-term economic gains against the social repercussions that may come with it for the environment and the native residents.

Name the specific issue you will address within that theme.

Applying an ethical framework offers systematic steps in considering the intersectionality of issues that the Standing Rock Resistance implies. Many of the elements related to utilitarian ethics, which are based on the principle of the greatest good for the majority, can be applied when evaluating the gains of constructing the given pipeline in relation to the losses. From a practical perspective, those in charge would consider whether, on balance, doing so is financially profitable compared to the effects on the environment and indigenous peoples.

Describe the prominent ethical dilemma you think exists in this topic.

Another vital framework is known as the deontological ethical theories, which are based on the principle of understanding that an action is justified only when people follow certain moral principles and rules. Using a deontological approach, it is unlawful to disregard the treaties and rights of those indigenous communities while practising the use of pipelines, even though it has a positive impact on the economic status of the society. This framework places justice and the inherent rights of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe first, including activities that promote adherence to promises and unity with the protection and respect of all stakeholders’ entities.

Explain the benefit of using an ethical framework as it relates to your topic.

The ethical framework assists in identifying the stakeholders and how their interests will be managed within the moral framework to ensure that the firm gets the best out of them. For instance, stakeholder theory also makes it possible to foresee what such problems may lead to for all the parties, including indigenous communities, activists, businesses, and the general population. With this method in mind, one can bring about a more empathic discussion, which considers all concerned parties and looks for a solution that will cause the least suffering while maximizing the good for all players involved.

COMMUNITY HEALTH AND POPULATION-FOCUSED NURSING FIELD EXPERIENCE — C229 REGULATED —NIM1 — NIM1 TASK 1: SOCIAL MEDIA CAMPAIGN

Explain how diverse ethical perspectives can benefit how your topic is addressed.

To address the problem identified in this evaluation, bringing in multiple ethical views can significantly enrich the discussions surrounding the Standing Rock Resistance. Indigenous people’s knowledge of the land may be spiritual or religious in origin, and in this way, indigenous peoples place value on ecological issues that Westerners tend to disregard.

Such concepts like deep ecology that characterize conventional Western environmental philosophy also embrace the interconnectedness of all ecological systems and the intrinsic imperatives of environmental conservation beyond the perceived utility of the environment to humanity. This perspective, however, is now appealing for reconsideration of the pipeline owing to its impact on various sensitive ecosystems and biodiverse areas.

On the one hand, both economic and business ethics underline the development, proclaiming energy independence as necessary and promoting economic growth. This view indicates the pipeline is an essential strategic asset; hence, more people may support increased safety standards and legislation to provide their protection instead of the pipeline’s elimination.

Enlisting these many ethical considerations can be relevant and inclusive, making it possible to foster an appropriate consideration of the environmental, social, and even economic contexts. This plurality contributes to the creation of new thinking as it relates to finding ways of establishing pipeline corridors that will not impact sacred grounds or designing new and improved means of avoiding potential oil leaks.